Current location:Earth Edges news portal > opinions
EDITORIAL: Diet behind the times in dealing with same
Earth Edges news portal2024-05-22 10:46:34【opinions】4People have gathered around
IntroductionIn a ruling on a same-sex marriage lawsuit, the presiding judge of a high court made a sincere appea
In a ruling on a same-sex marriage lawsuit, the presiding judge of a high court made a sincere appeal to the Diet, emphasizing the urgent need for measures to rescue people facing a daily sense of loss. How will the Diet respond?
In the first appeals court ruling in a cascade of lawsuits challenging whether provisions in the Civil Law and Family Register Law that do not recognize same-sex marriage are compatible with the Constitution, the Sapporo High Court on March 14 declared that the lack of legal recognition for same-sex unions violates Articles 14 and 24 of the Constitution.
While the Sapporo District Court at first instance deemed the situation a violation of Article 14, which establishes equality under the law, the high court went a step further by finding it in violation of Article 24, which defines the freedom of marriage and states that laws concerning marriage and family be based on the dignity of individuals.
The high court ruling goes further than the decisions by district courts across the country in referring to the Diet’s responsibility.
The first paragraph of Article 24 mentions the “mutual consent of both sexes” in relation to the freedom of marriage. The high court interpreted it as defining “the freedom of marriage between people,” stressing the importance of considering not just the wording but the social background that has recognized individual dignity.
It judged that the Constitution guarantees the freedom of same-sex marriage to the same extent as that of heterosexual marriage. The ruling prioritized relief for same-sex couples, based on the recognition that such couples, who are denied the protection of legal marriage, are in a situation where “the personality that constitutes an individual’s dignity is damaged.”
In a separate lawsuit, the Tokyo District Court the same day ruled the Civil Law and other laws were in a state of violating the second paragraph of Article 24. Of the six district court rulings on the constitutional issue that have been handed down so far, two declared the current lack of legal recognition of same-sex marriage was “unconstitutional” while three others said the situation was “in a state of unconstitutionality.”
There has been a clear and solid trend in the judiciary toward recognizing the unconstitutionality of the lack of marriage equality.
Even the Osaka District Court, which found it “constitutional,” mentioned the possibility of it being deemed unconstitutional in the future. All these district court decisions called on the Diet to make a prompt response.
A survey by The Asahi Shimbun in February last year found that 72 percent of the respondents said “same-sex marriage should be recognized by law.” More than 390 local governments have introduced a “partnership system” acknowledging relationships between two people of the same sex, covering more than 80 percent of the population.
Is the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, which has not even started discussions with the aim of introducing legislation to recognize same-sex marriage, unaware of the shift in the public’s perception toward accepting the existence of same-sex couples as a natural part of society?
After the Sapporo High Court handed down the ruling, one of the plaintiffs said: “My partner and I have reached the ages of 49 and 52 and we are starting to feel old. The longer the legalization (of same-sex marriage) is delayed, the shorter the time we can enjoy (the benefits) becomes.” One plaintiff in the Tokyo lawsuit had died.
Commenting on the high court judgment, Prime Minister Fumio Kishida, in a March 15 Upper House Budget Committee session, mentioned that other lawsuits are continuing and said, “We will continue to closely monitor the judgments.”
If the government and the Diet continue simply watching the judicial decisions, they at some point will stand accused of having failed to do the right thing.
Various social systems are based on heterosexual marriage. It is time to start working on consistent legislation to support marriage equality. There is no time to waste.
--The Asahi Shimbun, March 16
Address of this article:http://greenland.graduatethesis.org/article-51d199910.html
Very good!(83)
Related articles
- Vatican makes fresh overture to China, reaffirms that Catholic Church is no threat to sovereignty
- Experts on Taylor Swift’s poetry in ‘The Tortured Poets Department'
- House Speaker Mike Johnson risks job to deliver aid to Ukraine
- 'The Met Police are making no
- Microsoft's AI chatbot will remember everything you do on a PC
- How Taylor Swift's British ex Joe Alwyn kept dignified silence during six
- Debate over tight end value hovers over Brock Bowers' draft prospects
- 'Bluey' hits the mark with children and adults alike
- Kentucky congressman expects no voter fallout for his role in attempt to oust House speaker
- Wondrous Xinjiang: Xinjiang's mobile bazaar blooms ahead
Popular articles
- Pogacar extends Giro lead to over 7 minutes after winning altered Stage 16 amid protests at start
- South Africa man convicted in deaths of 2 Alaska Native women faces revocation of U.S. citizenship
- Judge drops some charges against ex
- Worker electrocuted while doing maintenance on utility pole in upstate New York
Recommended
Kansas takes control in the ninth and beats Kansas State in the opener of the Big 12 Tournament
'The Met Police are making no
Canucks' Rick Tocchet among new coaches making an impact in leading teams to NHL playoffs
Firefighters douse a blaze at a historic Oregon hotel famously featured in 'The Shining'
New Zealand Black Caps fans look to Twenty20 World Cup with hope, trepidation
Prosecutor won't bring charges against Wisconsin lawmaker over fundraising scheme
Angela Rayner makes her second visit to a housing project in just four days
The EPA is again allowing summer sales of higher ethanol gasoline blend, citing global conflicts
Links
- Grand Canal to get refilled with water in all dried
- View of spring in Beijing
- Xiplomacy: How China Helps Preserve Cultural Heritage Sites in Asia
- HK eases restrictions on travel, integrates with national devt
- View of Bayi Village in China's Chongqing
- Bringing on the summer tourism heat
- Xi Visits City of Cangzhou in North China's Hebei Province
- Tourists enjoy cherry blossoms in Changning, Hunan
- Scenery of Baiyangdian Lake in Xiongan New Area, N China's Hebei
- E China's Jinzhai County promotes industrial integration, agro